There are people who put chimichurri on choripán. And there are people who like to FEEL the chimichurri. That it burns, that makes you tear up a bit, that wakes you up. If you’re one of the latter, this recipe is for you.

This is not your grandmother’s chimichurri (unless your grandmother is tough). This is the one that makes you drink three glasses of water and say “give me another chori” at the same time. The one your friends ask you for with respect. The one that makes you famous at the asado.

Here I tell you how to make it without ending up in intensive care. Because yes, it has to be spicy. But it also has to be tasty. A sauce that only burns and has no flavor is useless.

Real time: 15 minutes (+ 2 hours rest so it doesn’t kill you) Yields: 8-10 well-loaded choripanes Spice level: 8/10 (can go up if you’re brave) Difficulty level: Same as classic, with more precautions

What You Need (commando version)

Base Ingredients (same as classic)

  • 1 cup fresh parsley finely chopped (leaves only, stems are bitter)
  • 6 large garlic cloves (yes, 6, don’t be lukewarm)
  • 3/4 cup oil (olive or mix with sunflower)
  • 1/4 cup red wine vinegar
  • 2 tablespoons dried oregano
  • 1 teaspoon coarse salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon black pepper

The Fire Givers (HERE’s the difference)

  • 2 tablespoons chili powder (double the traditional)
  • 1 tablespoon crushed chili (those with seeds)
  • 2 fresh hot peppers (jalapeños, serranos, or what you get)
  • 1/2 teaspoon cayenne pepper (this is already evil)
  • 1/2 teaspoon hot smoked paprika (for flavor, not just pain)

Optional (for suicidal)

  • Tabasco-style hot sauce: 5-10 drops
  • Fresh rocoto: If you get it, half a chopped rocoto
  • White pepper powder: 1/4 teaspoon (stings differently, more treacherous)

IMPORTANT: Before starting, wash your hands. And afterwards TOO. Don’t touch your eyes. Or nose. Or… well, you know. I’m serious, don’t say I didn’t warn you.

How to Make It (with all precautions)

Step 1: Preparation of Spicy Ingredients (this is key)

First things first: if you use fresh peppers (jalapeños, serranos, etc.), cut them in half and remove the seeds. That’s where it’s MOST spicy. If you want it to really burn, leave some seeds. If you want it edible for normal humans, remove them all.

Pro tip: Do this with disposable gloves. It’s not a joke. Pepper oil stays on your skin and then you scratch your eye and end up in emergency explaining to the nurse how you were so stupid.

Chop them very finely. The finer, the better the spice distributes. If you leave them in big pieces, you find surprise bombs in the chori.

Step 2: The Garlic (now we’re serious)

With six garlic cloves, this is no longer chimichurri, it’s a culinary exorcism. But hold on, raw garlic is what gives it character.

Chop it very finely or press it. Some mash it in a mortar with a little salt until it’s like paste. Works perfect because garlic becomes more integrated and the spice doesn’t hit you so localized.

Attention: If you have sensitive skin, after touching peppers and garlic, wash with soap AND with oil. Oil dissolves spicy oils that water alone doesn’t remove.

Step 3: The Parsley (your lifesaver)

Parsley here is not decoration, it’s survival. It’s what balances all that fire and turns it into sauce and not a chemical weapon.

Wash it well, dry it until there’s not a drop of water (if it stays wet, chimichurri will be watery), and chop it fine fine fine.

The more parsley, the kinder the spice. If you’re new to this, use a bit more than the recipe says. If you’re already a veteran, you can use a bit less for more spice.

Step 4: Mix Everything (THIS is the secret)

Here you don’t do it in any order. Order matters because vinegar “cooks” the spicy ingredients and garlic a bit, removes what’s most aggressive:

  1. In a glass bowl (plastic keeps garlic smell for three generations), put mashed garlic and all spicy ingredients
  2. Add all dry spices: salt, pepper, oregano, chili powder, cayenne, paprika
  3. Pour complete vinegar and LET IT REST 5 MINUTES. This is KEY. Vinegar softens raw garlic and makes spicy ingredients release their flavor better
  4. Add chopped parsley and mix well
  5. Finally the oil and mix everything until uniform

Why in this order? Because if you put oil first, vinegar can’t do its magic with garlic and spicy ingredients. And parsley oxidizes and gets ugly if you expose it to vinegar too long before adding oil.

Step 5: Rest (NON-NEGOTIABLE)

This is no longer advice, it’s an OBLIGATION. This chimichurri CANNOT be used just made. If you use it right away, it’ll be chaos of aggressive raw garlic and spicy ingredients that hit you at random moments.

Minimum 2 hours in the fridge. Better if you make it today to use tomorrow. During that time:

  • Garlic loses raw aggressiveness
  • Spicy ingredients integrate with oil and distribute evenly
  • Oregano releases all its aroma
  • Flavors mix and round out
  • Oil turns green and charges with all flavors

Pro parrillero tip: Make it the day before and leave it in fridge overnight. Next day taste and adjust if it needs more salt, more vinegar, or more spice (suicidal).

Step 6: The Test (carefully)

After resting, taste it. But NOT with your finger straight to the jar. Dip a small piece of bread and taste.

If it seems too spicy, add more oil and more chopped parsley. If it seems weak (psychopath), you can add a few drops of hot sauce or more crushed chili.

Important: What you taste straight from the fridge is less spicy than when you put it on hot chori. Heat activates spicy ingredients. Remember that before overdoing it.

Secrets Nobody Tells You

Secret 1: Oil is your friend Oil transports and distributes spicy ingredients. If you overdid the fire, add more oil. Doesn’t dilute flavor, distributes spice.

Secret 2: Sugar saves lives Half teaspoon of sugar (yes, sugar) removes aggressiveness without removing spice. It’s magic. You won’t taste it sweet, just less violent.

Secret 3: Rest multiplies spice This just made is spice level 6. Tomorrow it’s level 8. Day after it’s level 9. Increases over time. Consider that when preparing.

Secret 4: Cold calms it If you overdid it and it’s too fierce, serve it cold from fridge. Cold slightly numbs taste buds. Don’t serve at room temperature.

Secret 5: Not all spicy ingredients sting the same

  • Chili powder: Stings up front, fast, and leaves fast
  • Cayenne: Delayed sting, rises gradually and lasts longer
  • Fresh peppers: Stings fresher, less sharp
  • Crushed chili with seeds: This is treacherous, stings random

Secret 6: Parsley is NOT decorative Fresh parsley counteracts spice. It’s science. If it’s hitting you hard, eat a fresh parsley leaf. Helps.

Secret 7: Have dairy nearby Water does NOT work against spice. You need fat. Milk, yogurt, ice cream, cheese. That does neutralize. Have a bottle of milk in the fridge the day of the asado.

Errors That Will Ruin Your Day

Error 1: Touching your face Chili powder is tricky. You think nothing happens, you scratch your eye, and discover the true meaning of pain. Gloves, or at least wash your hands every two minutes.

Error 2: Tasting it just made Just made is pure chaos. Violent raw garlic, uneven spicy. After 2 hours in fridge it’s another sauce. Don’t be anxious.

Error 3: Using spicy ingredients of dubious origin Expired or old chili powder doesn’t sting, just makes bitter. Use fresh spices. Go to a health food store or market, get recent chili powder.

Error 4: Measuring by eye Spicy ingredients are NOT measured by eye. A tablespoon is not a tablespoon if you don’t flatten it. Be precise or you’ll have random results.

Error 5: Serving it to your in-laws without warning If you invite people, WARN that this stings. Not everyone has the same tolerance. Have normal chimichurri as backup. In-laws don’t forgive.

Error 6: Storing in plastic Plastic absorbs garlic and spicy smell. Then your tupperware smells like chimichurri for three years. Glass, always glass.

Error 7: Preparing for kids Kids don’t handle this. Make them normal chimichurri or just don’t put anything on them. Don’t be that guy who ruins a kid’s first parrilla experience.

Variations (for advanced suicidal)

“Reaper” Version (level 10/10)

Add half habanero pepper or a piece of Carolina Reaper. This is no longer food, it’s a challenge. Sign a waiver first.

“Smoked Infernal” Version

Smoke all peppers on grill first. They get deeper flavor, less aggressive on attack but more persistent.

“Trinidad Scorpion” Version

If you get Trinidad Scorpion peppers (you won’t, nobody sells them), half unit is enough to make 20 people cry. Only for the brave.

“Balanced” Version (spicy but reasonable)

Use only jalapeños without seeds + chili powder. Stings nice but doesn’t destroy you. Ideal to share with normal people.

“Andean Rocoto” Version

If you get Peruvian rocoto, half chopped rocoto gives fruity spice, different. Less aggressive, more complex. Very good.

How to Use It Without Dying

On choripán: One tablespoon. NOT TWO. One. If you want more after, serve yourself more. But start slowly. Hot chori intensifies spice.

As marinade (for masochists): Leave chicken or pork in this 2 hours before cooking. Turns out spicy but tasty. Don’t do it with fish, you’ll ruin it.

In empanadas: One teaspoon INSIDE each meat empanada before closing. Explodes flavor when you bite. Warn your guests.

With provolone: A melted provolone slice with a drizzle of this chimichurri. Cheese calms spice. Lethal combination.

On pizza: Drops over a mozzarella pizza. Not much. Try. Will blow your mind.

How to Store It

In fridge: Glass jar well sealed. Lasts 7-10 days. Spice increases over days, consider it. Oil separates, mix before using and done.

In freezer: Up to 3 months. In ice cube trays (each cube is one serving), or in zip bag well flattened. Thaws fast.

Pro tip: If you freeze it, when you thaw it will be MORE spicy than when you froze it. Flavors concentrate. Keep that in mind.

Questions Everyone Asks

How spicy is this really? On 1-10 scale, this is an 8. Stings hard but still edible. If you’ve never eaten anything spicy, start with traditional.

What do I do if I overdid the spice? Add more oil, more parsley, and a bit of sugar. Sugar is key, attenuates without changing flavor.

Can I burn my skin with this? No, don’t worry. In mouth it stings, on skin it can irritate if you’re sensitive, but doesn’t burn. Still use gloves when preparing.

Are fresh peppers mandatory? No. You can make it only with dried peppers (powder, crushed, cayenne) and it’s perfect. Fresh ones add more complexity.

Which pepper is most spicy? Carolina Reaper is world champion. Then Trinidad Scorpion. Then habanero. Jalapeño is mildest of “real spicy”.

Can spice be softened after made? Yes, with more oil, more parsley, and time in fridge. Or add a bit of heavy cream (weird but works).

Can I use chili powder from Chinese store? You can, but it’s not the same. Argentine chili powder has another level. Go to health food store or market and get the good one.

How much oil do I add if I overdid it? 2 tablespoons at a time, mix, taste. Repeat until it’s in your tolerance zone.

The Final Truth

This chimichurri is not for everyone. And that’s okay. It doesn’t have to be liked by everyone.

But if you’re one of those who likes to feel what you eat, for the flavor to shake you up a bit, for choripán to be an experience and not just a sandwich, this is your chimichurri.

First time make it on a Saturday, to try. Don’t debut it at an important asado. Try it, adjust it, get the hang of it. Second time you’ll already have it down.

And when you master it, you’ll be the guy everyone asks “bring that spicy chimichurri you made last time”. That’s the best compliment that exists.

Legal warning (seriously): If someone tells you they don’t tolerate spicy, DON’T give them this “to try”. Respect others’ limits. This chimichurri is for those who like it, not to torture innocents.

Follow us on Instagram: @choripan_com_ar

More recipes and guides: